The Right Way to Cook Kraft Dinner

Kraft DinnerIn honour of Canada’s 150th, and by popular demand, once published in a different context, here is

The Right Way to Make KD

Kraft Dinner is a much maligned food product, loved by some and mocked by many. In my observation, a big part of the problem comes from the fact that often when people have tried it and not liked it, they made it wrong. Well, even a good steak can be cooked poorly and become almost unpalatable; the same is true with this fine Canadian food staple. So here is my attempt to get you to give KD another try, cooked the right way.

First of all, get the basic KD, not some of the many variations with different types of noodle and cheese mixes that Kraft has for some reason pumped out into the market. Why try to improve on perfection? And, make sure you are dealing with actual Kraft Dinner, not some other brand attempting to capitalize on the success of this product.

Now, get a pot of water boiling, ideally a no stick pot, and use more water than they tell you to use in the instructions. You want lots of water, not just enough to cover the noodles. The idea is to get the noodles in there with enough water to keep a rolling boil that pretty much does all the stirring for you. If you are not using a Teflon coated pot, you will probably need to stir almost constantly to keep the noodles from sticking anyway.

While the noodles are cooking get a colander in the sink, and get out your butter and milk so they will be ready for the rapid steps which will soon be required.

Forget about using a timer to tell you when the noodles are done; use taste testing. DO NOT under any circumstances overcook them into a mushy state; that is the equivalent of cooking a t-bone steak to the well-done stage, which is of course unethical and may even be a sin.

When the noodles are done, that is, cooked but not overcooked (often referred to as “al dente”) you are now at the most critical stage of the process.

(Note: Pasta that is cooked al dente has a lower glycemic index than pasta that is cooked soft. Just one more reason to do it right!) If anything, err on the side of under cooking the noodles.

*Important Edit: Thanks to Laura Chee for correcting my evil practice of rinsing off the noodles. See her comment below this post.
Immediately turn off the burner and turn on the hot water over your sink. Dump the noodles into the colander and rinse very quickly (2.7 seconds to be precise but 3 seconds is also okay) with the hot water. Stir and shake the noodles to get excess water out of the mix. Leave the noodles for a second and shake the cooking pot dry before putting in a *dollop of butter. DO NOT use a light margarine which contains a lot of water.

(*Note: A dollop in this case is slightly more than the quarter cup called for in the recipe. Since we’ve already lowered the glycemic index of the noodles a little extra fat is just fine.)

When the butter is half melted in the bottom of the pot, give the noodles another stir and shake and dump them into the pot. Stir in the butter with the pot tilted slightly toward you. This will cause some of the butter to pool in the bottom corner allowing you to take a couple spoonfuls of hot noodles with melted butter, which is really quite tasty. If you are cooking for guests don’t let them see you do this.

Finish stirring the butter evenly into the noodles. Then open the “cheese” envelope and shake it over the noodles. Stir the cheese in until the noodles start to bind, but stop before you tear that precious pasta.

CRITICAL STEP: Add the milk. DO NOT use the amount they call for in the recipe as this will make your KD runny and more like noodle soup. This is a common mistake of beginners. Add a splash of milk and mix it in. Keep adding small amounts of milk (literally 1-2 tablespoons at a time) until the cheese mixes in smoothly and there is a slight amount of cheese sauce pooling in the corner when you tip the pot sideways. Next to not overcooking the noodles, not flooding the pot with milk is the most important step.

Take a couple spoonfuls from the bottom corner of the pot; it’s very tasty and is your right as the cook to enjoy. Again, conceal from any nit-picky germophobe guests who may be present.

Serve and eat immediately while it’s still hot.

The best side dish with KD is jalapeno cheese smokies made with wild meat. Also BBQ’d steakettes or deep fried grouse nuggets.

The Ketchup Issue: Some purists believe that KD should never be eaten with ketchup. Ketchup is in fact acceptable under the following conditions: 1) You have eaten more than half of your KD serving already and it is getting cold, and 2) The ketchup you use is French’s. (Anything except Heinz is acceptable. No true Canadian should ever use Heinz ketchup after what they pulled in Leamington.)

Leftover KD: Leftover KD should be placed in a sealed container in the fridge and hidden from the kids. When you are ready to eat it (as a night snack for instance during an episode of Dragon’s Den) you can either mix in some Bullseye BBQ sauce and heat it in the microwave or fry it in a no stick pan. Add the Bullseye after frying.

Another option is to have it for breakfast, by starting to fry two eggs and then spreading the KD around them to get heated up. I’ve never actually tried a KD omelette but see no reason why it wouldn’t work.


The Italians say that the character of a man can be determined by the way he eats spaghetti. The character of a Canadian is determined by the way we cook and eat our KD.

P.S.: It’s called Kraft Dinner not “mac ’n cheese.”

29 thoughts on “The Right Way to Cook Kraft Dinner”

  1. Hi Darren,
    That is the perfect recipe. My mouth was watering as I read your instructions.
    I guess I would be classed as a purest in this case. The only time ketchup is acceptable is if you didn’t follow this recipe correctly.
    Now chase that down with Pastor Darren’s chocolate chip cookies and you have had a feast!

  2. I have to say, Darren, this article has saved me (and my guests) from the hassle of reading the box, and being disappointed once again. I am concerned about the population who hasn’t yet discovered the good news! Thank you for sharing your experience.

  3. My his husband and I have a question he insisted to use cold water first then bring it to a boil l say you can use hot water from the tap then bring it to a boil hense not using as much hydro which one is right lol thank you

    • I’m always reluctant to get involved in domestic conflicts, but this is a serious matter. I must inform you that your husband is correct. Fresh, cold water is the way to go. Who knows what’s going on inside that hot water tank? Additionally, to get hot water from the tap requires running the water long enough to fill the pipe with hot water the whole way, most of which is then left to cool off once you turn off the tap. So using the stove likely uses less energy.

  4. Rinsing the noodles is a sin and I refuse to accept this part. Washing even a tiny bit of that starch off that makes the sauce nice and creamy makes my heart hurt. Everything else is exactly on point and is should be praised to the heavens. Your ketchup comments are also the correct reality to live in.

    • Hmmm… I will need to reflect on this. Perhaps I will need to confess of my starch-washing sins and repent. I think this calls for a taste test…

      • If you’re not using heavy cream, I don’t even know how to describe what you’ve been missing. Our Canadian way: Noodles in colander. Melt butter and stir in heavy cream. Stir until warm. Then whisk in sauce packet until smooth and gooey. Then add noddles. C’est magnifique.

    • I have tested your practice and agree- this is the right way to do it! In addition to saving a bit of time, it really does help make it even more creamy. Who knew that it was possible to improve upon perfection!

  5. Very nice recipe.
    Here’s mine that I think you might enjoy.

    0.5 kg lean ground beef (or any kind of fresh meat, ground or diced – canned meat or tuna do not suit this recipe, but it’s your stomach so…)
    2-5 cloves garlic (minced – at least two, but more is better)
    1 onion (diced – recommend red)
    30 mL soy sauce
    ground black pepper (however much you want)

    1 pkg Kraft Dinner (original)
    50g shredded cheese (and/or 2-3 process cheese slices – makes it creamier)
    2 tbsp graded Parmesan (fresh is best)
    100 mL half and half (10%) cream (sooooooo much better than milk)
    30-50 mL butter (margarine if you – ugh – absolutely must…)

    — If you want to rinse noodles, do so before cooking them, not after —

    In wok/sauce pan, heat up with a bit of olive oil, add meat, garlic, onion, soy sauce, and pepper. You can add a pinch of salt, but you really don’t need to. Reduce heat to 3/4 max.
    Stirring occasionally, you’ll want the meat at least to a light brown, but I like to go rather dark here. This also gives the onions and garlic a bit longer to break down and distribute their flavors.
    Once sufficiently browned, add a *sprinkle* of water, then cover and reduce heat to low until macaroni needs to be drained.
    – meanwhile –
    In a medium microwave-safe bowl (≥1.5 L), add cream and butter. Heat on high for 60 seconds.
    Stir in cheese powder until lumps are gone. Add shredded cheese and/or cheese slices. It is not expected for these to melt much, so just make sure it is decently mixed in with the sauce. If you use cheese slices, breaking them into pieces before adding them helps a bit.
    It doesn’t really matter where you fit this in the process so long as it’s done by the time the macaroni needs to be drained.
    – meanwhile –
    In pot, adding a pinch of salt and plenty of water (at least 2:1 water to noodles), heat until tiny bubbles form, add macaroni and stir to prevent clumping/sticking until water begins to boil. Reduce heat to 3/4 of max.
    Once the macaroni has achieved ‘al dente’, it is time to turn off all heat sources, then dump the macaroni into a colander. Stir around a bit to help the water drain.
    At this point, the macaroni, meat, and cheese sauce are thoroughly combined in the large bowl. You can mix in the Parmesan now, or sprinkle it over each dish as it’s served.

    Satisfies one VERY hungry individual, makes a decent lunch for two, or works up to four if served as a side dish.

  6. Wow, finally I know why my Kraft dinner NEVER turns out. Always, always sticky/mushy! My family always scoops it out in chunks. I’m so grateful to have found the right way to do it. Thank you! This article had me laughing out loud several times — laughter is good for the soul, so thank you for that too 🙂

  7. The Nova Scotian way to make KD:

    Pre-boil your water, set a timer and throw in your pasta and let it boil hard for exactly 9 mins stirring occasionally and scraping the bottom so nothing sticks.

    At the same time throw a half pound of hamburger in a cast iron pan with 1/4 of a diced onion and fry until its all good and brown, add a few shakes of salt and pepper and for the last few minutes throw in a few diced garlic cloves to take the heat off it and bring out the flavour.

    While this is going on prep a medium sized stainless steel bowl with the following ingredients:

    Cheese sauce powder
    1/4 cup loose (as in, don’t pack it! too cheesy is a very easy line to cross…) grated old cheddar
    3 tablespoons salted butter (fuck margarine)
    3 tablespoons coffee cream (a.k.a. 18% cream)

    Drain pasta well with a colander using the “drop and stop” motion to ensure it is free of excess water and dump that in your stainless steel bowl with your sauce ingredients and stir until well combined.

    Pull your pan ingredients to the side and tilt the pan so the excess beef fat pools at the bottom (this dish already has a high healthy fat content and we don’t want it to be so greasy it makes your face sweat and you almost shit yourself running to the bathroom) and carefully mix the ingredients into your bowl containing the KD

    Now insert a large spoon into the center, it should almost stand up. Mmm, hearty. strip down to your underwear, grab a 4 litre (thats a gallon for you ‘mericans) jug of homo milk (a.k.a. whole/full fat/homogenized milk) and go to your living room and watch tv as you eat the whole bowl and drain half the jug whilst doing so.

    Congratulations, you’re now an honorary Nova Scotian.


Leave a Comment